Sponsored

Car Magazine UK Review (GT and EcoBoost)

Helios1234

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Threads
12
Messages
242
Reaction score
43
Location
England
Vehicle(s)
Ford Mondeo/Porsche Cayman S
Ford Mustang (2015) review

By Chris Chilton
First Drives
26 September 2014 07:20


The arrival of the sixth generation of the iconic Ford Mustang isn’t just a big deal for America, this time it’s a big deal for UK car fans thanks to right-hand drive and a modern Euro-friendly downsized engine.

But forget living out those Bullitt fantasies for a minute: is it actually any good? Read on for CAR magazine's Ford Mustang review.

A RHD Mustang coming to a Ford dealer near you? Well, I suppose it only took them 50 years...

The Mustang’s compact size means cars have been coming to the UK since the first one was launched back in 1964, but this time there’ll be no messing with import duty and VAT, or steering wheels on the wrong side. And no wincing every time you fill the tank, because as well as the expected 5.0 V8, which now produces 420bhp, there’s also a 2.3 Ecoboost four derived from the 2.0 in the Focus ST.

A four-cylinder Mustang! Joe McCarthy must be spinning in his grave.

Yurpeans seem to think every Mustang ever built was a fully paid-up muscle car with 10 squillion bhp from a flame-shooting V8, but in fact many of them were powered by meek four- or six cylinder engines and not remotely fast.

But this time the four-pot is being billed as a performance engine. Punching out 310bhp and 300lb ft of torque, it’s as powerful as the V8 was when the fifth-generation car launched, and will hit 62mph in around 5.5sec (around a second behind the new V8). That’s not bad considering the car must weigh the wrong side of 1600kg.

The reality is it’s been tuned purely for torque. It pulls hard from around 1500rpm and keeps pulling until 5k-ish, but there’s nothing at the top end, it’s a little laggy, and it doesn’t sound anywhere near as good as a Focus ST.

It’s an effective engine, but compared to something like the Golf R’s motor, it’s nowhere in terms of fun. We don’t have EU fuel consumption figures yet, but expect around 35mpg on the combined cycle.
Click here for an interview with the Ford Mustang design team.

What about corners? The new 2014 Mustang does do corners, right?

It certainly does, and surprisingly well, though we’re talking competent and entertaining here, rather than anything that rewrites the rulebook. The electrically assisted steering isn’t particularly quick, but it’s surprisingly precise and gives a fair idea of what the front wheels are up to. But the big news is at the back, where the Mustang gets independent rear suspension for the first time since the early-noughties SVT Cobra range-topper. It absolutely transforms the driving experience. The ride is settled and you never have to worry about mid-corner bumps deflecting you from your course.

US spec base-model cars are rather soggy, but all Brit cars come as standard with the usually-optional Performance Pack, with its stiffer suspension and limited slip diff. Of the two, the V8 feels the more serious, although its tighter damping comes at the expense of a a chunk of ride comfort. The V8 is also the only one with enough grunt to let you indulge in lazy tyre-smoking antics.

But even the four-pot looks like it could smoke its tyres for three blocks, and I suppose that’s half the battle.

Ford Mustang design: inside and out

This is a great-looking car, one with enough Mustang cues to keep aficionados happy, but strong and modern enough to stand on its own. And this time the interior looks like it cost more than five cents to put together.
It’s more overtly retro than the exterior and apart from some lower dash plastics, feels like a quality construction. Shame about the rear seat space. The back of a BMW 2-series feels positively palatial by comparison, and the Mustang’s boot (not hatch, note) has an awkward opening.

Verdict

In previous years, you had to buy into the whole Mustang heritage to justify one in Europe, and even then you had to put up with too many compromises. This time the ‘Stang is a genuine rival for cars like the BMW 2-series, VW Scirocco and Audi TT, but, sad to say, the Ecoboost is not the stand-out car in the line-up.

A 228i M Sport is roomier, matches it on price and performance, and will cost far less to run. If you can handle the extra running costs, the beguiling V8 (more rumble, more tyre smoke, more Mustang, and only £4k more) is absolutely worth stretching for.
http://www.carmagazine.co.uk/Drives/Search-Results/First-drives/Ford-Mustang-2015-review/
Sponsored

 

martin

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2014
Threads
147
Messages
677
Reaction score
102
Location
New England
Vehicle(s)
Ecoboost; coupe; guard; dark-saddle; MT; PP; Nav;
Oh dear. Not a great review. The reviewer prefers the Focus, VW Golf
 

GTsquid

Guest
He's talking about exhaust when it comes to the Focus. I also find it hard to take seriously anyone that thinks he should be able to whip it around like a VW Golf.
 

mikeyw

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2014
Threads
2
Messages
67
Reaction score
0
Location
England
Vehicle(s)
Merc C Class
Don't percieve these reviews as so negative. He actually scored it an overall 4 out of 5.

Yes, he said the Focus ST somehow sounded better and the engine doesn't feel as nice as the Gold R's. Also it's a bit tight on rear seat space.

Overall though it's not bad, because he didn't really complain about ride comfort or interior quality.

What's kind of becoming apparent from UK reviews and is maybe what I was feeling myself, is that the V8 is the one to go for. Which is kind of surprising.
 

martin

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2014
Threads
147
Messages
677
Reaction score
102
Location
New England
Vehicle(s)
Ecoboost; coupe; guard; dark-saddle; MT; PP; Nav;
Another UK review, Telegraph, actually comments on a disappointing interior quality, compared to European cars (and 1 Japanese car)
 

Sponsored

genericuser1

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2014
Threads
0
Messages
194
Reaction score
2
Location
Mid-Atlantic
Vehicle(s)
2011 M3 convertible
The thing that concerns me is the rear seat comment. If the 2 series has a bunch more room the Mustang may be a no go for me. I can't have anything smaller back there than my car.
 

fionic

spaghettios and cheerios
Joined
Jun 8, 2014
Threads
9
Messages
3,181
Reaction score
616
Location
IL
Vehicle(s)
15 GT PP
The thing that concerns me is the rear seat comment. If the 2 series has a bunch more room the Mustang may be a no go for me. I can't have anything smaller back there than my car.
why are you buying a mustang if you need a back seat?
 

OppoLock

RWD Addict
Joined
Apr 21, 2014
Threads
43
Messages
3,098
Reaction score
870
Location
St. Petersburg, FL
First Name
Sean
Vehicle(s)
'15 GT, '20 GT350
Vehicle Showcase
1
Don't percieve these reviews as so negative. He actually scored it an overall 4 out of 5.

Yes, he said the Focus ST somehow sounded better and the engine doesn't feel as nice as the Gold R's. Also it's a bit tight on rear seat space.

Overall though it's not bad, because he didn't really complain about ride comfort or interior quality.

What's kind of becoming apparent from UK reviews and is maybe what I was feeling myself, is that the V8 is the one to go for. Which is kind of surprising.
Right, thank you. As soon as a reviewer offers up a dash of criticism or prefers another car in a specific category, it's gloom and doom for the S550. Ok then. :doh:
 

Malikona

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2014
Threads
10
Messages
543
Reaction score
11
Location
Denver
Vehicle(s)
R1
An 228i M-sport matches the EcoBoost on price? Not in the USA it doesn't...
 

Sponsored

OppoLock

RWD Addict
Joined
Apr 21, 2014
Threads
43
Messages
3,098
Reaction score
870
Location
St. Petersburg, FL
First Name
Sean
Vehicle(s)
'15 GT, '20 GT350
Vehicle Showcase
1
Oh dear. Not a great review. The reviewer prefers the Focus, VW Golf
Did you read the whole thing? The comparison was made specifically in regards to the EB's engine versus the R's. I hope you understand the difference between a Golf and an R.
 

Lord Thunder

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2014
Threads
13
Messages
1,124
Reaction score
229
Location
The Hague, The Netherlands
First Name
Erwin
Vehicle(s)
2015 RR GT Mustang
The only things that will go on my back seat are bags, coats and the occasional guineapig-carrier. Should fit just fine.

Ow, and maybe an occasional sister-in-law .. like I said: Should fit just fine. :D
 

Lord Thunder

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2014
Threads
13
Messages
1,124
Reaction score
229
Location
The Hague, The Netherlands
First Name
Erwin
Vehicle(s)
2015 RR GT Mustang
An 228i M-sport matches the EcoBoost on price? Not in the USA it doesn't...
I just checked the Dutch BMW price list .. the M235i has a 6 cylinder, with less CO2 emissions than the EB. 189g vs 199g. It's priced just shy of 60k EUR here. The Mustang EB should come close. According to my estimates around 55k EUR for a loaded Premium PP EB. (The V8 Mustang will be way more expensive here than that.)

PS: There is no M version of the 228i available here.
 

doulos4jc

......looking^
Joined
May 8, 2014
Threads
101
Messages
2,003
Reaction score
314
Location
Maryland
Vehicle(s)
2015 Turbo Mustang
The thing that concerns me is the rear seat comment. If the 2 series has a bunch more room the Mustang may be a no go for me. I can't have anything smaller back there than my car.
Back seat not meant for adults, period!(serious)
 

Malikona

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2014
Threads
10
Messages
543
Reaction score
11
Location
Denver
Vehicle(s)
R1
I just checked the Dutch BMW price list .. the M235i has a 6 cylinder, with less CO2 emissions than the EB. 189g vs 199g. It's priced just shy of 60k EUR here. The Mustang EB should come close. According to my estimates around 55k EUR for a loaded Premium PP EB. (The V8 Mustang will be way more expensive here than that.)

PS: There is no M version of the 228i available here.
The CHEAPEST 2-series you can get in the US is the RWD 228i - with NO OPTIONS - and that starts at $32,100. That's what you would pay for a very-well-equipped EcoBoost.

I don't know how the pricing and taxes and everything work in the UK, but this just isn't an apples-to-apples comparison pricewise in the United States. The EcoBoost is a steal over here (heck so is the V8).
Sponsored

 
 




Top